Blog · Law
Personal Injury Settlement Amount Examples (2026)
Personal injury settlement amount examples (2026), each with a public source, from average insurance claims to nuclear verdicts, and what moved each number.
By Tavrn Team · · Updated · 4 min read
Summarise with ChatGPT, Claude or Perplexity

Personal injury settlement amount examples (2026) range from the average auto injury claim of $28,278 [1] to jury awards over $300 million [14]. Most claims resolve near the low end. The examples below each link to a public source, and the amount usually tracks injury severity, fault and the proof behind the damages.
The typical claim is small
Big verdicts make the news. Ordinary claims do not. Insurer data is the best public view of the typical case.
In 2024, the average auto liability claim for bodily injury was $28,278 [1]. For dog bites and other dog-related injuries, the average cost per claim was $65,450 in 2025 [2]. Those averages include claims that settled without a lawsuit.
Large verdicts are a separate group. The U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform counted 1,288 verdicts of $10 million or more between 2013 and 2022 [3]. The median for that group was $21 million, and auto accident verdicts had the same median [3]. These cases are rare, but they shape what both sides expect.
Sourced settlement and verdict examples
Each row below is a public, reported case. Most are jury verdicts, because settlements are often confidential. A verdict can still be cut, appealed or settled for less.
Case | Type | Injury or claim | Amount | What moved the number |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Spokane school bus, 2026 | Verdict | Girl struck by a school bus | $115,000 [4] | Jury found her 90% at fault [4] |
Miami-Dade Metrobus | Settlement | Partial leg amputation | $4.3 million [5] | State cap of $200,000 per person needed a claims bill [5] |
Costco parking lot, NJ, 2026 | Verdict | Back injuries after a crash | $5.2 million [6] | Insurer disputed whether the crash caused the injuries [6] |
Super Target, Florida, 2025 | Verdict | Injuries at a store | $11,391,183.28 [7] | Jury found Target 90% at fault [7] |
Vail Resorts, Colorado, 2025 | Verdict | Skier paralyzed after chairlift fall | $12.4 million [8] | Cut from $21.1 million for fault and the state cap [8] |
Placer County, CA, 2026 | Wrongful death | Motorcyclist killed in a collision | Nearly $16 million [9] | Family sought $45 million; defense argued about $4 million [9] |
Connecticut motorcycle, 2021 | Verdict | Marine paralyzed in a crash | $45 million [10] | $36.5 million was noneconomic damages [10] |
Philadelphia, 2026 | Verdict | Birth injury | $108.6 million [11] | Medical malpractice claim against a hospital system [11] |
Florida Keys Tesla, 2025 | Verdict | One death, one critical injury | $242.6 million [12] | $200 million was punitive damages [12] |
Levy County, Florida, 2026 | Verdict | Head-on crash with a drunk driver | Over $301 million [13] | $200 million for pain and suffering, $100 million punitive [13] |
What moves a settlement amount
The table shows the same few drivers again and again.
Injury severity and permanence
Permanent injuries drive the largest numbers. The two paralysis cases above produced awards of $12.4 million and $45 million [8][10]. In the Connecticut case, the jury awarded $8.5 million in economic damages and $36.5 million in noneconomic damages [10]. Pain, lost function and future care can outweigh past bills.
Shared fault
Most states reduce an award when the injured person shares the blame. Justia's survey finds that over 30 states use modified comparative negligence, about a dozen use pure comparative negligence, and only a few still use contributory negligence [14]. In the Spokane bus case, the jury found the girl 90% at fault and the driver 10% at fault [4]. The Colorado skier's award was reduced for her 25% share of fault before the state cap applied [8].
Damage caps and government defendants
Some states cap certain damages. Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 74.301, noneconomic damages in a health care liability claim against physicians are limited to $250,000 per claimant, with separate limits for health care institutions [15]. Claims against governments face their own limits. Florida's sovereign immunity law caps payouts at $200,000 per person and $300,000 per incident unless the Legislature approves more [5].
Punitive damages
Punitive damages punish conduct rather than pay for harm. In the Tesla case, $200 million of the $242.6 million award was punitive [12]. In the Levy County drunk-driving case, punitive damages were $100 million [13]. Many cases have no punitive claim at all.
How damages are argued
The number a lawyer asks for can matter. A study of 732 mock jurors found that a lump-sum demand anchored the size of awards [16]. The same study found no effect from per diem anchors of a similar size, which price pain by the day [16]. In the Placer County case, the jury's award sat between the family's request and the defense figure [9].
Proof of causation
Insurers often contest whether the incident caused the injury. In the Costco case, the defense argued that back injuries could have come from other activities, including lifting a dog [6]. The jury still awarded $5.2 million [6]. Complete treatment history is what lets a firm answer that argument with records instead of testimony alone.
Why the medical record sets the ceiling
Every driver above depends on documentation. Severity is shown through imaging, operative notes and therapy records. Causation is shown through the timeline of care before and after the incident. Future care is projected from the treating providers' own notes.
Missing records cut both ways. A gap in treatment invites a causation fight. A missing provider can leave real damages out of the demand.
Getting the complete record with Tavrn
Tavrn retrieves medical records from any US provider: one authorization in, complete record out, via platform, integration or API. It reaches around 425,000 provider organizations across all 50 states and DC. Every open request is followed up automatically every 48 hours, and records arrive as each provider responds.
For law firms, that means a fuller record before the demand goes out, not after the first denial. See how it works in a demo.
Sources
- Facts + Statistics: Auto insurance — Insurance Information Institute, 2025
- Spotlight on: Dog bite liability — Insurance Information Institute, 2026
- New U.S. Chamber research shows nuclear verdicts continue to increase in size and frequency — U.S. Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform, 2024-06-04
- Jury awards $115K to girl hit by Central Valley school bus, finding she was 90% to blame — The Spokesman-Review, 2026-11-02
- Legislature OKs payment to man who lost leg after Metrobus crash — Florida Politics, 2026-03-11
- Costco parking lot crash verdict in New Jersey — Courier News / MyCentralJersey, 2026-05-04
- Winter Garden woman wins $11.3 million in lawsuit against Target — Orange Observer, 2025-10-21
- Broomfield jury finds Vail Resorts negligent, awards injured skier $12.4 million — The Colorado Sun, 2025-09-04
- Jury decides Kings minority owner Phil Oates must pay $16 million in crash civil case — The Sacramento Bee, 2026-09-15
- Marine paralyzed in motorcycle crash wins $45 million verdict — Patch, 2021-03-21
- Jefferson Health hit with $108.6 million verdict in Einstein birth injury case — The Philadelphia Inquirer, 2026-03-20
- Jurors blame Tesla for fatal Florida Keys crash, award victims $242 million — Miami Herald, 2025-08-01
- Florida mom awarded $301 million after being hit head-on by drunk driver — Naples Daily News, 2026-11-12
- Comparative & contributory negligence laws: 50-state survey — Justia
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, Chapter 74, Section 74.301 — Texas Legislature
- Anchoring, per diem arguments and damages awards — Washington University Law Review, 2017


